November 14, 2026 – Good Intentions

Let me just begin with, WHAT ON EARTH WAS I THINKING?

Well, I can tell you…

I was thinking that perhaps I could find purpose and meaning and give a child an opportunity to experience something that might help them to see that there are other possibilities. That maybe their life could be different, maybe even better, than what they envisioned for themself. Maybe, just maybe, as a result of spending time with me and getting to see and do things that they ordinarily don’t get to do, that they might find hope along the way.

That’s what I was thinking.

It all started out innocently enough. I went to a volunteer fair at the local senior center and while perusing all the vendors in attendance, I happened upon a table with flyers for a program much like Big Brothers/Big Sisters.

“Hmmmm,” I thought to myself, “This has potential!”

The leaflet or flyer discussed the need for mentors for at-risk youth in the community. As I write this, I think I skipped over the part that mentioned ‘at-risk’ when I initially combed over the information.

And what is this organization exactly, you wonder? In theory, they facilitate pairing you up with a child for a year-long commitment, with the end goal being that the experience for both mentor and mentee is mutually beneficial.

So, if you want the long story short, I lasted less than three weeks in the program. Yep. Despite all the efforts made by the program coordinator to ensure I was adequately educated (i.e.; what I was about to step in), I brushed it aside and proceeded with anything but caution. “I’ve got this!” I confidently told myself. I mean, how hard could it possibly be?

Oh, Honey, let me tell you…it was HARD!!

Knowing my mentee’s backstory (let’s call her Mara) really pulled at my heart strings. It was bad, really bad. Think Dexter bad. When she was a toddler, some really terrible sh*t went down. And it was significant enough that it was all over the news; however, after giving myself plenty of time to process the information, I wasn’t put off in the least. At first.

And I have to say, I was in high spirits when I initially met Mara and her mom. Mom was a sweetheart and Mara, being a freshly-minted teenager who had just turned 13 the previous week, seemed like she was open to the partnership despite her clipped responses and lack of eye contact. I’ve had teenagers, I get it.

Visit number one went reasonably well but I let things get away from me. I hadn’t recognized how important boundaries were so I allowed for things I wouldn’t ordinarily allow (even with my own kids). It was hard to say no, especially when she’d look at me with those damn doe eyes.

The visit consisted of treating her to a belated birthday meal at her favorite restaurant, whereby she could choose anything off the menu. She did. We then went to a store in the nearby mall so she could spend the money she’d received for her birthday. After she nearly emptied her wallet on a shirt and a hoody in a single store, we decided to peruse the rest of the mall.

Eventually we came upon Bath and Body Works, at which time I purchased Mara some perfume. Her favorite. Afterward, we loaded everything into the car and I drove her back home, stopping off briefly at yet another restaurant in order to indulge her with an iced coffee.

Once we arrived back at her apartment, I had barely pulled into the parking space and shut off the engine, before she hopped out (recent acquisitions in hand) and made a beeline for her front door. After she entered, she shut it firmly behind her. There was no goodbye, no thanks, no nothing. Hmmm? I had to wonder.

Visit number two never happened because Mara’s mom called me the night before I was scheduled to pick her up to let me know her daughter was feeling under the weather and would be staying home. I was disappointed because I’d gone to a considerable effort to come up with fun things to do, but that’s ok. Life happens. I understood.

Visit number three seemed to go as well or possibly even better than visit number one. At the appointed date and time, I once again swung by her apartment; however, this time there was a significant delay when I knocked on the door. When her mom got around to answering it, I discovered my mentee still in her pajamas, fast asleep on the couch.

After a bit of scrambling, we eventually made it out the door and were able to commence with the afternoon’s planned activities. I’d spent a significant amount of time (earlier in the week) trying to come up with affordable/cheap things to do, particularly after getting a good look at my credit card charges after visit number one, and saw that the local library was offering watercolor classes. For FREE!

That’s what I’m talking about!!

She absolutely loved it. And on top of getting a chance to try her hand at watercolor painting where all the supplies were provided at no charge, she was also able to sign up for a library card and check out several books. Ensuring her daughter got a library card was a request her mother had made of me when we initially met and something I promised I would fulfill.

After the library, we drove to a local burger joint. Mara had mentioned countless times how hungry she was as we applied paint to paper during the watercolor session, so I decided to take her out for a meal before dropping her off at home. “You can choose something off the kids’ menu,” I informed her as we entered. I’d recognized that I needed to start imposing boundaries after things got away from me during our initial visit.

She ordered a cheeseburger, which came with fries and a drink. I did the same. When we sat down at the table, we sat across from each other. When the food was brought to us, she scarfed down her meal and then followed it up with ice cream.

Things had gone fairly well up to that point, but I have to admit, the longer we sat, the more annoyed I became. In addition to insisting I share my fries with her, she kept continually reaching across the table in an effort to snatch them off my tray. That’s a no-no in my book. As the youngest of 9 children who grew up impoverished during my formative years, I don’t like people helping themselves to food on my plate or my tray. That is, unless I offer. And I hadn’t.

After the restaurant, I drove her back home. When I pulled into the parking lot, it felt like déjà vu. Once my vehicle came to a stop, she hopped out (library books in hand) and made a beeline for her front door. And after entering, shut it firmly behind her. There was no goodbye, no thanks, no nothing.

I dutifully followed, as I wanted to let her mom know how everything went. Upon knocking on the door, her mom opened it and I entered. I wasn’t sure where Mara had gone but she was absent during the conversation in which I gave her mom the lowdown on the afternoon’s events (omitting the part about the French fries). She was really pleased that things had gone well and that her daughter could now utilize the library (which was just down the road) at her leisure.

As I prepared to leave, I saw Mara reappear (from her room?). She had changed into her pajamas and was walking in my direction. However, she didn’t approach me. Instead, she made her way towards the living room and plopped down on the couch. What followed? Well, I’ll put it this way, what followed was the catalyst to the whole thing unraveling and all my good intentions going down the drain.

With my hand on the doorknob, I turned to leave. However, before I did, I looked in her direction in order to say goodbye and it was at that time that she made an effort to finally acknowledge me. What came out of her mouth was like a dagger to my heart. I expected something like, “See you next week,” or “I had a great time!” Instead, she coldly said, “I CAN REPLACE YOU.”

I thought I had the fortitude to see this thing through. I really cared about this family and this young girl, but that singular statement sent me reeling.

The organization I signed up with as a mentor had forewarned me about all the possibilities I was likely to encounter and, in my naiveté, I chose to overlook them. And for nearly a week and a half after the hurtful words Mara spoke, I barely slept. I ruminated for days on end and then I ruminated some more. I wanted to keep my commitment but those words, THOSE WORDS! I couldn’t see my way past them.

I was distraught and felt terrible but I knew what I needed to do. And after a mere 3 weeks, with a heavy heart, I composed a letter to the organization responsible for the mentor/mentee program and notified them of my immediate resignation. The subject line read as follows: MORE THAN I BARGAINED FOR.

Yes, I felt like a jerk. A loser. An abysmal failure. And I felt infinitely worse (if that’s even possible) when they sent their reply. I refer to it as the SHAME letter. It contained everything I expected and rightfully so. To put it briefly, they let me know that regardless of how much they prepared me, I ultimately let them down and possibly retraumatized the child, something which they took great pains to avoid.

Sh*t.

So, after a lot of soul searching, which followed a great deal of self-admonition, I took the time to ask myself the same question I usually ask myself when things don’t go as planned, “What did I learn from this?”

Well, I learned that it’s not a good idea to mentor an at-risk child, especially a freshly-minted teenager, when I haven’t even worked through my own childhood trauma. If I haven’t been successful at ‘fixing’ myself, what hopes do I have at ‘fixing’ someone else? I also learned that it’s probably best to steer clear of the annual volunteer fair for obvious reasons. And lastly? I learned that maybe it’s time to put the brakes on ‘finding a purpose’ because each time I try, regardless of how things start out, let’s face it, they simply don’t end well.

Sigh…

Love and blessings to you and yours.

Until next time…

Leave a Reply